Box breathing usually means a counted inhale, a pause, an exhale and a pause. It is popular and works well for some people. For others, the holds feel uncomfortable, the counting feels like a test or a pause is the last thing they want when they are already tense.
Holds and fixed counts are optional, and you can leave out any that feel uncomfortable. The six options below keep breathing easy. They are not treatment for a medical condition.
1. General steadiness
Sit comfortably and notice a few ordinary breaths without holding them. Counts are optional. If you count, choose a pace with no strain, for example in for four and out for four, and drop the holds.
You might rest a hand on your lap or on your belly if that helps you follow the breath. Your attention can drift and come back as often as it needs to. There is no target number of breaths.
2. Winding down
For an evening pause, let breathing stay easy. Let the out-breath be a little longer if that is comfortable. Do not force it or expect to fall asleep.
Dim the lights, put the phone down and sit or lie somewhere supported. If a longer exhale makes you feel tense or breathless, skip it and simply follow your ordinary breathing.
3. If holding feels unpleasant
If holding the breath feels unpleasant, leave out all holds. There is nothing to work up to.
Some people feel a sense of panic or tightness when they pause. That is a good reason to drop the pause altogether. Easy, continuous breathing is a complete practice on its own.
4. Before a presentation
Before a presentation, take a minute of ordinary breathing, with a gentle count if it helps you focus.
Do it in a quiet moment, such as in the corridor or while waiting. Feel your feet and the weight of the papers or the laptop in your hands. Then walk in. If you like, you can look around the room and let your gaze rest on something steady.
5. In a stressful public moment
For a stressful public moment, feel the chair or floor and keep breathing naturally. Chest pain, severe breathlessness, fainting or other concerning symptoms need medical help, not a breathing pattern.
On a train, in a meeting or in a queue, nobody will know you are doing anything. Press your feet down, let your shoulders drop and notice a few ordinary breaths.
6. At bedtime
At bedtime, let your breathing be natural, or listen to a quiet sound in the room. Do not use long exhales or holds to try to force sleep.
Trying hard to fall asleep tends to backfire. If you cannot sleep, rest anyway and try to be in the room as it is: the weight of the blanket, the sound of a fan, the dark.
Choosing between them
If you are not sure which to try, let the situation pick. Need to steady yourself in public: use the feet-and-chair version (5). Winding down at night: the easy evening version (2) or just listening (6). A few minutes before something important: ordinary breathing with an optional gentle count (4). If any of them make you feel worse, that is useful information. Switch to just feeling your feet and looking around the room, and leave breathing alone for a while.
Why not just do the standard version?
You can, if it works for you. The point is that you have a choice. Some people enjoy the structure of box breathing and find it easy. Others find the structure itself stressful. If counting makes you anxious, you do not need it. If pausing is uncomfortable, you do not need it. A practice that you dread is unlikely to be one you will return to.
A note on the holds
Stop if dizzy, breathless, distressed or uncomfortable and return to normal breathing. If symptoms persist, skip counted patterns for now. People with heart or lung conditions, pregnancy, panic or other medical concerns should discuss deliberate breathing exercises with a qualified clinician. Never practise breath holds while driving, in water, or where fainting would be dangerous.
Related: ordinary breath awareness, feet on the floor and supported rest.

